Rusty’s

Reviews

• Anthony S.

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  Rave rave rave......
  Rusty's has been our go to pizza since moving here three years ago. Drinks are good, service is always ok and food (lunch or dinner) is always well done.
  Rave for today..... went in last night and they had just run out of wings, so I ordered my pizza and sat down. Rusty walks by and I looked up st him and said "rusty your out of wings" and boom..... he was gone. He was back less than ten minutes later with a load of wings for the cooks and when my pizza was being eaten an order of wings hit my table.... oh yeah...... that's taking care of your customers.

• Lindsey R.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 11 June 2026

  This was our first time trying Rusty's and we were very dissatisfied.
  
  No major complaints on the bar itself but the pizza wasn't what I expected. There was a burnt taste to the crust and some pieces were very heavy on cheese where others had barely any. The overall flavors were not good and my 8 year old son refused to eat it.
  
  On a positive note...I can say the cheese squares were good.

• Jenny Z.

  star star star star star 4 June 2026

  This place blew my mind in so many ways.
  Kids were starving and so we needed to stop and grab food quick. I didn't even look on Yelp or Google but just saw Rusty's as we drove by. I told my husband to make a u-turn and we parked easily.
  walking in, I was reminded of every amazing restaurant that I went to as a child. Authentic wood. Old School advertisements. Plastic mustard and ketchup squirt bottles.
  Honestly, I was so enamored with the atmosphere that I wasn't really counting much on the food. The food was shockingly amazing. We ordered a cheeseburger with bacon, medium rare. It was juicy, thick and hard to put my mouth. French fries were perfect. Chicken sandwich with bacon and swiss. Yum! And the potato salad, as advertised by our waitress, Veronica, was amazing. I'm not even a really big fan of potato salad, but this one made me happy. Delicious.
  Service was amazing. Food blew my mind. This is definitely on my to do list when I travel past.

• Claudia H.

  star star star star star 31 May 2026

  Stopped here on the way to Shoreline to see a concert. I was only there briefly, but it was a very chill place. Huge bar! I loved the environment, the music, the beer, and definitely the pizza! I believe we ordered the combination... It was on hit!

• Lori B.

  star star star star_border star_border 27 May 2026

  The pizza and beer are really good with great prices.  But the music was blaring, so loud that we could not even talk.  We had a party of 10 for a birthday party.  And when we asked the bartender to turn it down just a tad she told me she couldn't because Rusty just turned it up.  If we hadn't just ordered and paid for our pizza we would have probably left.  Someone in our group asked again and they finally turned it down a little.  I'm a fan of music and I do like it loud but not when you and friends are trying to have a conversation.   Saw the owner and thought maybe he would stop and say hi.  Seems like it kinda a clicky place.  We didn't quite fit in I guess.